Advanced Format Drives Plus WHS – A Match NOT Made in Heaven

We mentioned the other day a post by PricklyTech on how to add an advanced format drive to your Windows Home Server storage pool. But what he hadn’t considered was the performance of the drive, since one reader was only getting 40 Mb/s on his advanced format drive.

So the writer tested his newly added Western Digital WD20EARS drive and found also that the its performance was slow, with testing not being able to complete and the drive totally disappearing from the disk management console.

Conclusion – Although advanced format drives are fine in Vail DO NOT use them in Windows Home Server v1.

More here.

69.png

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

6 Responses to “Advanced Format Drives Plus WHS – A Match NOT Made in Heaven”

  1. John Maloney Says:

    I use a WD20EARS drive as the primary drive for my home built server and haven’t had any issues with it since I used WD tool to set it up to use the drive format in WHS. Initially it was very slow, but I ran the tool right after finishing the install and before I had data on the drive. Here is the link to WD version of Acronis True Image WD Edition Software,
    http://support.wdc.com/product/downloaddetail.asp?swid=119&wdc_lang=en

    Hope this helps anyone that might get one of these drives.

  2. Justin Says:

    John,
    I’ve been told not to use the Green drives as primaries (OS drives) because they like to sleep too much and will cause performance issues since they will have to wake up and spin up so much. Have you noticed anything like this?

    Do you know what the WD ‘tool’ did to the drive to make it work appropriately?

    Justin

  3. John Maloney Says:

    The tool I linked above, WD version of Acronis True Image WD Edition Software, is the tool I used. It has a fuction to reset the partitions to the old cluster size. I wish I had known about the recommendation about the green drives, but I haven’t haven’t noticed any problem with lower performance. I don’t do anything to taxing on the system, though. I use it to store my video and music files and watch and listen to them over the network. The only time I noticed a problem was when I was copying a large file to the server, listening to mp3’s and watching a ripped DVD at the same time. The music and movie were stuttering every once and awhile, but I think that is the crappy Netgear gigabit switch that is connecting it all together. I just noticed that issue recently and I’ve been running the Western Digital Caviar Green WD20EARS 2TB since April 2010.

  4. Mike Says:

    I did not use the Align Tool on my drive as I had read that the Align Tool did not work on WHS or would cause issues if one Advanced Format drive was jumpered and another one was not. Glad that you guys are happy with your drives …

  5. Gary Says:

    Jeez, yet another scare story about these drives.

    1. Buy advanced format drive (get used to them, most new models of drives from all manufacturers will be advanced format now including lower capacity laptop drives)

    2. Apply jumper

    3. Put into WHS

    4. Proceed as normal – no slow down, no issues.

    I’ve got 8 or 9 of these WD drives in my windows home server and have not had a single problem. All you have to do is apply the jumper BEFORE INSTALLATION to warn the drive it’s dealing with XP/2003 era windows and off you go. The WD align tool is not supported in WHS … I’d recommend against it.

    Only thing to remember is to remove the jumper if you later use the drive in WHS2/Windows 7 etc

  6. AGAIN Do not use Advanced Format disks in WHS v1 « MS Windows Home Server Says:

    […] Advanced Format disks in WHS v1 August 25, 2010 — Philip Churchill After our warning the other day about using advanced format hard drives in version 1 of Windows Home Server, Microsoft have also […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: